Ep #49: Visiting Wild Horses in Winter II
March 10, 2025A Win for Wild Horses: Cash Incentive for Adoption Overturned in Federal Court
Federal Court Overturns BLM’s Controversial Cash Incentive Adoption Program by Amelia Perrin
The national Adoption Incentive Program was exposed by plaintiffs & The New York Times as a pipeline to slaughter for thousands of adopted wild horses and burros
(DENVER, Colo., March 3, 2025) – In a landmark victory for wild horse protection, the United States District Court for the District of Colorado has overturned the Bureau of Land Management’s (BLM) controversial Adoption Incentive Program (AIP), ruling that it violated multiple federal laws by failing to undergo required National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and Administrative Procedures Act (APA) requirements.
The court found it was “not hard to imagine” that slaughter of wild horses could be “fairly traceable” to BLM’s actions regarding the national AIP program, and noted the legally required need for vigorous public comment and agency review, which the BLM failed to conduct.
The decision comes in response to a lawsuit filed by Eubanks & Associates, PLLC on behalf of American Wild Horse Conservation (AWHC), Skydog Sanctuary, Carol Walker and other petitioners, who argued that the program, which pays individuals $1,000 to adopt wild, unhandled wild horses and burros, incentivized the unnecessary suffering and slaughter of federally protected wild horses and burros.
Judge William J. Martínez found that the 2022 Instruction Memorandum (IM) establishing the AIP violated both the APA and NEPA, writing that: “an agency cannot avoid its notice and comment obligations by simply clothing instruction memoranda in permissive language, only to then treat them in practice as mandatory.”
As a result, the court vacated the 2022 IM and ordered the BLM to conduct proper notice-and-comment and environmental review procedures before implementing any similar legislative rules in the future, thereby overturning the current program.
Judge Martinez also quoted BLM’s own internal concerns that “[t]he easy money aspect [of the AIP] may bring out potential for fraud, abuse, and neglect,” and wrote that the front-page expose in the New York Times, and congressional action, followed the “advocacy efforts” of the petitioners.
“This ruling halts this corrupt federal program that has funneled hundreds of federally-protected wild horses and burros into the slaughter pipeline in violation of Congressional protections,” said Suzanne Roy, Executive Director of American Wild Horse Conservation, who noted that her group’s ongoing investigation of AIP was likely just the tip of the iceberg. “We’re grateful that the court recognized what we have long known — that the BLM’s program was not only unlawful but also fundamentally at odds with the agency’s duty to protect these iconic animals and treat them humanely.”
“This ruling is a powerful affirmation that the Adoption Incentive Program was a betrayal of these iconic animals, pushing them from public lands to slaughter auctions under the false promise of care,” said Clare Staples, founder of Skydog Sanctuary. “The AIP opened the floodgates and allowed thousands of wild horses and burros to enter the slaughter pipeline.”
Skydog Sanctuary has led efforts to rescue AIP animals from slaughter auctions and has saved hundreds of animals from this cruel fate.
“Our wild horses deserve to be protected and treated humanely, not turned into a commodity for profit and abuse. This decision returns to the wild horses that have been removed from our public lands the protection that they deserve,” said wild horse photographer and author Carol Walker.
The AIP was launched in 2019. Evidence presented in court — brought to light by an AWHC investigation, which prompted a widely publicized exposé in The New York Times — revealed that many adopters were pocketing the incentive money before quickly sending the animals to slaughter auctions.
The investigation revealed that groups of related individuals were adopting the maximum of four animals per person, then flipping them to slaughter auctions once titles were obtained, collecting tens of thousands of taxpayer dollars in the process.
The ruling found that the BLM failed to consider “whether limiting the AIP to untrained horses increases the likelihood of horses being slaughtered” and that the BLM failed to provide adequate evidence that its policies actually protected wild horses from being slaughtered .
In confirming the legal standing to sue, the Court quoted petitioners’ pleadings regarding their “grave aesthetic injuries” by being forced to witness “malnourished, injured animals in kill pens,” as well as observing “first-hand the inhumane treatment these federally protected animals must endure as a direct result of the AIP .”
“This victory belongs to every wild horse advocate who fought for transparency and accountability—and to the wild horses and burros themselves, cherished American icons who deserve protection, not cruel slaughter to end up as horsemeat consumed overseas,” said Roy.
AWHC remains committed to ensuring that the BLM adopts responsible, humane, science-based solutions to manage wild horse and burro populations on public lands and stands willing to collaborate with the agency on responsible adoption programs that puts the safety and welfare of wild horses and burros at the helm.
###
American Wild Horse Conservation (AWHC) is the nation’s leading nonprofit wild horse conservation organization, with more than 700,000 supporters and followers nationwide. AWHC is dedicated to preserving the American wild horse and burros in viable, free-roaming herds for generations to come, as part of our national heritage. In addition to advocating for the protection and preservation of America’s wild herds, AWHC implements the largest wild horse fertility control program in the world through a partnership with the State of Nevada for wild horses that live in the Virginia Range near Reno.
SKYDOG SANCTUARY is a forever home for wild mustangs and burros who have ended up in horrible and dangerous situations – at kill pens, at auctions, or in unloving homes where they have often been starved and neglected. We are also home to several wild horse families we have reunited after being separated during roundups.
Carol Walker is a wild horse photographer, advocate, podcaster and author based in Longmont, Colorado.
The Petitioners are represented in this litigation by the public interest law firm Eubanks & Associates, PLLC.
Watch here to see Carol’s interview with her three adopted mustangs about the decision as shown on Denver 9 News: